Energy Insights

Measuring E&P Capital Decisions in an Annual Incentive Plan is Complicated

Are E&P companies using the right metrics in their annual incentive programs?

Posted by on

There has been a lot of attention (both from the media and investors) focused on whether E&P companies are using the right metrics in their annual incentive programs. E&P companies have been criticized for a heavy focus on production and…

Controlling Activist Investors

Potential Texas legislation would curtail activist investors and proxy advisors.

Posted by on

While we wait to see what deregulation might come out of the new administration regarding Dodd-Frank or other executive compensation regulations, the Texas legislature might take a huge step in favor of corporate boards and management. A bill currently pending…

The Impact of Lower Stock Prices on 2016 Say on Pay

Many energy companies should anticipate tripping ISS's absolute stock price test.

Posted by and on

The current industry downturn is already impacting compensation programs and will likely also impact the upcoming Say on Pay season. Based on our research, the market decline will cause an increased number of energy companies to trip a key ISS…

The Impact of Lower for Longer

Oil prices seem to be remaining "lower for longer," so what does that mean for compensation?

Posted by on

In a previous Energy Insights post, Jim Wolf discussed the impact of $40 oil prices on early 2015 compensation decisions. At the time, energy companies speculated whether we’d see a “V”-shaped or “U”-shaped recovery. After a volatile summer – doubts…

Proposed Pay for Performance Disclosures May Actually Help

Benefits of the proposed disclosures include a standardized methodology for realizable pay and additional data that will facilitate shareholder analysis.

Posted by on

The SEC recently proposed rules outlining a new CD&A disclosure coming out of Dodd-Frank (see Meridian Alert here) – these rules require disclosure of the link between performance and compensation “actually paid”. While the proposed disclosures will likely require a…

Energy Industry Influences ISS Peer Approach

ISS recently released its policy updates for the 2015 proxy season, with one notable change.

Posted by on

ISS recently released its policy updates for the 2015 proxy season (Meridian summaries here and here). One notable change is ISS’s methodology for selecting peers for energy companies for use in its pay for performance analysis. This change was likely…

Should bonus outcomes be different by level?

Insights into whether there should be different standards for executive bonuses than for the broader population, and whether executives shouldbe held to a higher standard of accountability to shareholders.

Posted by on

In our experience, a large number of oil & gas companies provide the same bonus funding level for all bonus-eligible employees in the organization. There may be differentiation based on individual or business unit performance (horizontal differentiation) but no differentiation…

ISS Continues its Unpredictability

While ISS Remains Influential, Some of its Decisions are Inconsistent From Company to Company

Posted by on

The 2014 proxy season is almost over for calendar year companies. Based on our analysis, ISS continues to play an influential role and the energy industry continues to be one of their favorite targets, but it’s getting more difficult to…

Looking for Shareholder Value Drivers

Analyzing Common Annual Bonus Metrics to Predict Shareholder Value

Posted by on

Annual incentive metrics should be key drivers of long-term shareholder value. Most energy companies include this in their philosophy statements, and it sounds straightforward. But what are the drivers of long-term shareholder value? The answer to that question obviously varies…

Using Realizable Pay to Test Pay and Performance Alignment

Testing the Link Between Pay and Performance Can Help Firms in Many Ways

Posted by on

With the calendar year completed, many of our energy clients are taking this opportunity to test the long-term historical link of pay and performance. This historical analysis serves a few purposes: Helping the compensation committee understand whether they have an…

Questioning Total Shareholder Return

While Total Shareholder Return is Under Scrutiny, it Remains the Best Metric to Evaluate Performance

Posted by on

Relative Total Shareholder Return (TSR) has become the most common performance metric in long-term incentive plans across the energy industry. TSR is also the primary metric used by shareholders and proxy advisors like ISS to evaluate performance and test the…

Benchmark the Role, Pay the Person

Use Market Data to Make Informed Pay Decisions

Posted by on

Many energy companies are preparing to review market benchmark data in the next few months. When used correctly, market benchmark data provides a valuable tool to help make informed pay decisions, but should not be used without appropriate context. Below…

2013 ISS Recommendation Trends

ISS Recommendations for the Energy Industry are Looking Up This Year with Fewer Against Votes Than Last Year

Posted by on

We’re about midway through the 2013 proxy season and so far, the energy industry is faring better than last year with ISS. 12% of energy companies have received a Say on Pay AGAINST recommendation from ISS this year as opposed…

Telling Your Story

How to Prepare an Effective and Compelling Proxy

Posted by on

Most companies are getting ready to file their 2013 proxy statements and telling the story of their 2012 compensation. Effective proxies share a clear and compelling alignment between performance and pay. For most energy companies, however, compensation does not boil…