Insight Type: Key Insight
COVID-19 Impact on Retail Industry Incentive Compensation
Executive Compensation: Staying Focused on the Essentials
ESG and Incentives: Considerations for Small-Caps
How and Why Pre-Commercial Biotech CEO Pay is Different – Part Four: Drivers of Say-on-Pay Results
Managing Compensation Complexity
The Impact of COVID-19 on Executive Compensation Programs
Weighing ESG Metrics for Pay Plans
Lessons Learned: What will be the most critical governance issues companies must address post-pandemic?
Redefining Success – Incentive design and goal-setting in uncertain times
Back to the Basics: Re-examining Executive Compensation Design for the Upcoming New Year
Determining Annual Incentive Pay in a Pandemic
How and Why Pre-Commercial Biotech CEO Pay is Different – Part Three: East Coast vs. West Coast
LTI Mix—Does ‘Performance’ Matter?
Should ESG Metrics Be Included in Executive Incentive Plans?
Banking Industry Incentive Practices
How and Why Pre-Commercial Biotech CEO Pay is Different – Part Two: Founders vs. Non-Founders
Benchmarking in an Unusual Cycle
We expect that the typical fall benchmarking/market data process will look different for many oil & gas companies. The current commodity price and general economic environment will likely impact compensation levels across much of the industry, which will cause a few challenges when companies review survey data. ■ Industry volatility will likely impact peer group … Continued
COVID-19’s Incentive Impact: While Most Companies Wait, Companies with Early FYEs are Forced to Act
How and Why Pre-Commercial Biotech CEO Pay is Different – Part One: Tailoring Pay to the Business
The Impact of COVID-19 on Chemical Companies and Their Annual Incentive Programs
Banking Industry Response to COVID-19
Introduction The 2020 Coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic represents one of the most significant global events in recent history, resulting in unprecedented impact on our country’s economy, its businesses and its people. For our financial services clients, initial priorities focused on the safety of employees and customers. At the same time, many banks were thrust into the … Continued
Predicting the Future of E&P Bonus Design
E&P bonus plans have historically aligned with growth and investment, focusing on volume (production and reserves) and cost reduction, measures that are more controllable by management and less impacted by commodity prices than earnings-based metrics. In recent years, investors and analysts have been increasingly critical of E&P bonus payout misalignment with shareholder returns and financial … Continued
Survey Results: Oil & Gas Workforce and Compensation Strategies
Key Takeaways In our March survey results we reported an overwhelming majority of companies focused on emergency business actions and less on compensation considerations. As of the end of April, it appears companies have taken action on their now identified workforce and compensation strategies. Outlined below are some of the key takeaways. Impact on the … Continued
Announced Retail Executive and Outside Director Pay Reductions
Since the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic in the U.S., Meridian has monitored the unprecedented actions taken by retailers to enhance financial flexibility and offset the substantial impact to operations associated with prolonged store closures. These actions have included eliminating non-essential capital expenditures, drawing down revolving lines of credit, suspending dividends and share buybacks, eliminating … Continued
How should oil & gas companies approach their 2020 annual bonus?
“Wait and see” seems to be the mantra of the day, particularly when it comes to an energy company’s annual bonus plan. We think that’s a prudent approach for the moment, as much uncertainty remains among the energy industry and broader economy. However, as we think forward a few months, what alternatives might companies consider … Continued
The Impact of Recent Pay Actions on Severance Arrangements
These actions have included pay reductions, work furloughs, and layoffs. Among other matters, companies likely need to evaluate the impact of these actions on severance benefits. Multiple types of arrangements provide for cash and other benefits in the event of an employee’s or executive’s severance, including severance plans, severance guidelines, employment agreements, severance agreements, and … Continued
Bracing for a New Disclosure Rule on Executive Pay for Performance
A new and mandatory executive pay proxy disclosure requirement is about to hit. A remnant of the 2010 Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act, this pay-for-performance disclosure rule will become effective for most public companies shortly after the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) officially posts the final rules and a related comment … Continued
Survey Results: Oil & Gas Companies Contemplating Workforce and Compensation Strategies
Over the past couple weeks, energy companies have publicly announced actions to lower capital spending and reduce G&A costs in response to the COVID-19 pandemic and the Saudi/Russia price war. Over the last two weeks Meridian surveyed 45 companies in the E&P and Oilfield Service sectors to gauge the potential impact of these historic events … Continued
Oil & Gas Crisis Response: 2020 Compensation Responses will lead to Sustained Changes
Mere weeks after boards approved compensation outcomes from 2019 performance, there’s a temptation to revisit or change those outcomes under the lens of 2020 performance. We believe that in the large majority of cases, those 2019 outcomes should stand on their own merits. Current events will instead impact 2020 outcomes – meaningfully. We believe the … Continued
Revisiting Board Pay in a Time of Crisis
There is a clear appetite to set the right tone at the top as business leaders balance (a) keeping their workforce and customers safe and healthy with (b) navigating supply chain uncertainty and weakened demand for their products and services. The timing of this crisis—just as many calendar-year companies are planning for annual shareholder meetings … Continued
Compensation Implications of the Current Environment
That was rough… The week of March 9, 2020 may have marked the single worst week for oil and gas stocks on record. A lot has changed, and the only thing certain is that more change will come. Here is what we feel confident of: ■ E&P companies will re-set 2020 capital programs; early announcers … Continued
The $1 Salary: Lessons Learned
Periodically we receive requests from our clients to profile advantages, challenges, and best practices associated with administering pay programs that combine a very modest base salary with large equity grants. The $1 Salary Plan is the most extreme version of this approach, and the symbolism of such a program has proven attractive to a handful … Continued
Ready to Expand Your Clawback Policy? Not so Fast . . .
More recently, many have stopped waiting. In public company boardrooms across the United States and abroad, there is a growing trend to expand company clawback policies beyond current regulatory requirements to include additional triggers for addressing employee misconduct through the use of their clawback rights. The focus on clawbacks is in large part a result … Continued
How Should Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) Performance be Reflected in Executive Compensation?
Many of the public company boards and corporate executives (very notably, 181 CEOs signing the Business Roundtable Statement avowing Stakeholder primacy1) that are eager to demonstrate this responsiveness cite compensation as an existing, meaningful and highly visible tool that is increasingly being used to reward or penalize executives for ESG performance. The reality, however, is … Continued
Fostering Diversity in Board Pay Practices, Part Two
In recent years, we have observed a remarkable level of homogenization of compensation practices for non-employee directors, even as what is expected from board members of public companies continues to evolve and—generally speaking—expand. In our client work, we have also noted a great deal of diversity in the role that the board is expected to … Continued
Executive Pay Outreach
Historically, a company’s communication with investors has been centred around the quarterly tion of financial business results and forward-looking guidance, along with year- end results. However, developments over the past several years have led companies to engage with major institutional investors on a more frequent and individualized basis on executive compensation matters. The case for … Continued
Prepping Your Clawback Policy for Prime Time
In the wake of corporate scandals and high-profile executive misconduct, compensation committees are reviewing the adequacy of their clawback and forfeiture policies. Board members want to be assured they have the tools needed if they find themselves in the headlines. The original clawback provision under Sarbanes-Oxley requires only the CEO and chief financial officer (CFO) … Continued
Time to Check Your Equity Incentive Plan Share Reserve
This increase in share use also means that equity incentive plan reserves will drain at a faster rate, and may run out sooner than expected. Companies often ask for more shares when there is roughly enough left in the plan to cover one more year of normal cycle equity awards, in order to have a … Continued
Fostering Diversity in Board Pay Practices, Part One
In recent years, we have observed a remarkable level of homogenization of compensation practices for non-employee directors, even as what is expected from board members of public companies continues to evolve and – generally speaking – expand. In our client work, we have also noted a great deal of diversity in the role that the board … Continued
Why Pre-IPO Peer Groups are (or at least should be) Different
Most compensation committees review information gathered from a customized peer group of companies as part of compensation program development and relative performance reviews, and peer group construction is often a matter of significant debate. Common sense would suggest that if the goal is to understand what is competitive pay to attract and retain and motivate … Continued
Compensation: Quiet Before the Storm?
Compensation committees fared well in the 2019 proxy season, with the vast majority of Russell 3000 companies receiving support on their compensation programs from proxy advisors and shareholders. Yet, compensation programs continue to be a hot=button issue for stakeholders, with scrutiny of incentive pay metrics, goal rigor and policy transparency only intensifying. CBM recently spoke … Continued
Managing Executive Incentive Programs for Chemical Companies
This article offers some useful context and information for compensation committees and management teams of chemical companies to consider when designing and managing their executive pay programs. In particular, we cover key attributes of the industry and their impact on setting goals and designing incentives to help manage the impact of volatility resulting from: Commodity … Continued
Use Compensation to Advance ESG Initiatives
Directors should take a close look at how their companies can use compensation to advance an environmental, social, and governance (ESG) strategy. A key to ESG oversight is the board’s examination of how compensation reflects and advances the company’s commitment to ESG goals. Investors and other stakeholders package a broad range of nonfinancial topics under … Continued
Why Wait for Congress (and the SEC) Before Reviewing Your 10b5-1 Plan?
The bill includes six procedural restrictions for the SEC to study for consideration as potential amendments to Rule 10b5-1. The proposed restrictions prescribe a reasonable approach for administering plans based on sound governance practices. One might wonder why companies would wait for Congress (and the SEC) when they could consider these changes now. The SEC … Continued
EVA for E&P Companies: A Challenging Measure
While initially the EVA material will be provided purely for information, it seems inevitable that ISS will continue to push to include EVA as a formal part of its pay for performance analysis. There are general concerns about ISS using EVA – a complicated analytical framework that uses highly adjusted financial data – to make … Continued
The Revival of Excise Tax Gross-Ups?
This potential wave has generated questions about Change-in-Control (CIC) severance protections, amplified by the significant coverage of Anadarko’s last minute enhancements to its CIC severance programs (see article). The Anadarko enhancements included elevated severance benefits and the re-insertion of excise tax gross-ups. Most companies, including Anadarko, eliminated the use of excise tax gross-ups in new … Continued
Pay for Performance
Over the past ten years or so – since the widespread adoption of shareholder ‘say on pay’ votes on executive compensation at public companies in the US and elsewhere – arguably no single idea has animated the analysis and design of CEO compensation programmes as much as the goal of ‘paying for performance’. For a … Continued
Adding Economic Value: The Complicated Case of EVA for Financial Companies
In 2018, shortly after its acquisition of equity research firm EVA Dimensions, Institutional Shareholder Services (ISS) announced that it will include Economic Value Added (EVA) measures in advisory reports[1]. ISS believes EVA measures provide a clear and more complete picture of value creation. The challenge for financial companies is that EVA is a difficult metric … Continued
Market Data in Context
It is a quantifiable, objective way for a compensation committee to gauge how an executive is positioned versus the market, and helps the committee to understand what competitive pay is and if compensation arrangements are adequate to attract, retain and appropriately motivate executives. When proxy season ends, many companies will review market benchmark pay data … Continued